Lucky Charms and the parry

This situation comes up frequently in our group. The attacking warrior rolls a 6 and two 4s to hit. The defending hero has a lucky charm. He makes the 4+ roll and removes the 6. May the defender now parry?

If yes lets go further. One of the 4s is a red dice and one is white. The white die represents the dread dagger. The red die represents a sword. If our hero parries with a 5+ must he: declare which attack he is parrying? Remove the dice of his choice? Randomize?

We do a combination of all choices depending on who is being asked and who's asking.

For example we generally rule that the highest die is removed by the lucky charm instead of randomizing among the possible hits. And some of us argue that since you may not parry a 6, if a 6 is rolled you may not parry any attacks even if the 6 is removed by a Lucky Charm roll. But others say the 6 is removed before a parry so...

Any wisdom from the communtiy?

You would have to roll the dice one after the other so that you can tell which one is the first. Of course it is up to the attacking player to choose the order in which he makes his attack rolls. If the attacker rolls all his attack dice at once, then it is his own fault and the defender may decide which is the "first" attack that is removed.

So the attacker has to be aware of the potential existence of lucky charms and if he forgets, it is better for the defender.

That's how we play it.

I believe you have to nominate all your attacks att the same time, and therefore there is now certain order in which the attacks are actually made. For example, if you have 2A and fight in a combat with 2 enemies, where one is knocked down, you can't first role 1 dice to see if you managed to get the standing warrior, and save the last dice in case you didn't succeed in injuring him.

So somehow I say that you should be allowed to parry the other attacks, since the attack (6) that was put away buy the lucky charm is not a threat anymore. Though I agree it is a picky situation.
– popmouth

Parry rules (p36/37) state that you must beat the highest score of your opponent.

Lucky Charms say you may ignore the first hit. Hits are not calculated until all factors (such as parrying) have been resolved.

Therefore, you may not Lucky Charm then elect to parry the remaining scores.

That's the way I read it anyway.

I would play like Catferret.

In Death Squads we moved our "lucky charm" to ignore the first wound as parry and a few other skills could cause some issues.

Well I am learning a few things. Thank you for the replies thus far. Mainly I am reminded to look in the rule book.
In the main our problem is caused by throwing all the dice at once. At the same time in a system where a warrior can have up to 9-10 attacks throwing the dice one at a time is frustrating as well. But for most combats 2 or 3 dice are all we are talking about...

Lucky charms affect the first hit, so dice should be rolled accordingly. This will take a huge change in culture in our group. (We tend to throw lots of dice with explanations of what each one may mean to follow.)